The Donahey Law Firm, LLC
Free Consultation: Email


Home of the Million Dollar Verdicts
Offices Menu
Get Your FREE Case Review Talk to a lawyer for free with no obligation. Let’s talk.

FOR SERIOUS INJURIES, Call the Lawyers Other Lawyers CallTM

Supreme Court Considers Birth Injury Case On Malpractice Awards

In most birth injury cases, lawsuits end with a settlement or jury verdict in favor of the victim and his or her family. A recent case has made it all the way to the United States Supreme Court. This case could help thousands of injury victims in Ohio and around the country when the Court issues its decision.

The importance of this case involves a common tactic that many states bring in more revenue. A North Carolina law allows the state government to automatically claim up to a third of any medical malpractice award to pay itself back for helping cover the victim's costs with Medicaid funds.

So after a 12-year-old victim of severe c-section related birth injuries received $2.8 million in a settlement, North Carolina promptly claimed its third. The government says that it is entitled to this sum to reimburse it for the Medicaid funds that it spent to help pay for the girl's care before the settlement. Because the parties intended for this settlement to finance the girl's lifelong care costs, the government's share took a big chunk out of her much-needed long-term financial security.

This case is now looking at whether state governments can impose these kinds of automatic deductions without looking at the individual facts of each case. A more fact-specific look at this case might have caused the state to agree that it could not in good conscience take such a large portion of this family's settlement.

If the Supreme Court issues a favorable decision, it could help thousands of plaintifffs around the nation receive more compensation for medical malpractice injuries.

Source: Miami Herald, "Supreme Court weighs case of disabled child and medical malpractice award," Michael Doyle, Jan. 8, 2013

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Email Us Your Case Information For A Free Consultation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy


The Donahey Law Firm
495 S High St #300
Columbus, OH 43215

Telephone: 614-224-8166
Toll-Free: 800-792-1480
Fax: 614-849-0475
Email Us | Columbus Law Office Map

Branch Offices

Dayton Office
Local: 937-224-3030
Toll-Free: 800-792-1480

Cincinnati Office
Local: 513-721-9400
Toll-Free: 800-792-1480

Delaware Office
Local: 740-363-4969
Toll-Free: 800-792-1480

Covington Office
Local: 859-261-0572
Toll-Free: 800-792-1480

Mobile Office

Toll-Free: 800-792-1480
Learn More

Donahey Law Firm Logo
Logo: Facebook Logo: LinkedIn Logo: Twitter Logo: YouTube Logo: Google+